Halo: Reach Review Scores are out!

basilmarket.com forums : Chat | 16 posts archived

thread starter Kierkegaard Sep 11 2010 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

IGN: 10 IGN UK: 10 IGN AU: 10 Gamespot: 10 CVG: 10 1UP: A+ Eurogamer: 10 Eurogamer Italy: 10 Eurogamer Spain: 10 Eurogamer Portugal: 10 Edge Magazine: 10 Destructoid: 10 GamePro: 5/5 G4TV: 5/5 Giant Bomb: 5/5 GameShark: A+ GameTrailers: 10 Kombo: 10 MEGamers: 10 Boomtown: 10 GameSpy: 5/5 Kikizo: 10 Official PlayStation Magazine: 10

My Characters: JoyDivision - 13 Scania Magician

PyreFang 09/11/10 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

[quote] ThePepsi : I believe Super Mario Galaxy 2 deserves, and already has that title locked up. [/quote] Oh so? Interesting... How does one go about picking a game of the year anyway? By which games sells the most in X days/weeks since release? Or averaged ratings from all rating sites?

My Characters: iPyrefang - 15 Yellonde Magician

BoogerX + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

Troll... above Isn't just decided by editors of different gaming sites? Like each gaming site has different game of the year a lot of the time.

My Characters: Dexlssilbi - 121 Windia Hermit

Oxy12 09/11/10 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

anyone else think that the ratings above are a LITTLE biased? Because that's pretty much IMPOSSIBLE to get a perfect score from everyone. And besides nobody always likes the same thing as someone else.

My Characters: Oxy12 - 47 Broa Bandit

aaronboy25 09/11/10 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

Gah, too many good games are coming out within a short period of time! I need time between this, KH:BBS, Assassin's Creed Brotherhood, and possibly Black Ops. Not to mention I STILL need to get my hands on Galaxy 2 D:

My Characters: Azinmidget - 83 Khaini Dragon Knight

wintersfire 09/11/10 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

I've got a good idea for world peace! Stick a bomb inside each packet of the game. Each game that's open will create a deadly explosion.

My Characters: PandemicLove - 99 Khaini Sniper

NerdyMapleGeek 09/11/10 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

I'm pretty sure Gamespot didn't review it yet..

My Characters: Mightyarrow - 163 Scania Bow Master

ThePepsi 09/11/10 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

[quote] PyreFang : Oh so? Interesting... How does one go about picking a game of the year anyway? By which games sells the most in X days/weeks since release? Or averaged ratings from all rating sites? [/quote] Which game is most enjoyed wins the title. Any game can win, it's not limited to games that get 90+ or anything, but that's usually what is picked. Mario Galaxy 1 won GOTY already, and Mario Galaxy 2 is not only much better, it's the highest reviewed video game on current-gen consoles. (Except GTA IV cause i believe reviewers were bribed)

My Characters: ExcelIerate - 41 Bera Brawler

chaostheory 09/11/10 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

[quote] illkoyou : Oh. Yea I google'd reviews and only gamespot came o-o. ( I think it was like a 9.5 or something?) [/quote] lmao gamespot is for amateur gamers. they barely give out any 10s and lag out alot on there updates ><

My Characters: CorsairSpin - 86 Broa Outlaw

DarkRecon 09/11/10 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

I checked most videogame review sites, so far Game Informer is the only one who has reviewed it yet and gave it a 9.5. Besides, game's barely out yet. *places big sign that says Troll Thread*

My Characters: DarkReconz - 74 Bera Hermit

PyreFang 09/11/10 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

[quote] ThePepsi : Which game is most enjoyed wins the title. Any game can win, it's not limited to games that get 90+ or anything, but that's usually what is picked. Mario Galaxy 1 won GOTY already, and Mario Galaxy 2 is not only much better, it's the highest reviewed video game on current-gen consoles. (Except GTA IV cause i believe reviewers were bribed) [/quote] This is a stupid question but... how does one go about deciding which is most enjoyed? By how many are sold within the first... oh wait I asked that. Seriously though: If each site has a different game of the year, does one just compile which game has the most sites calling it the game of the year? And that's the winner?

My Characters: iPyrefang - 15 Yellonde Magician

Johasua 09/11/10 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

Fallout: New Vegas will win Game of the Year Fallout 3 was the only game ever that I really enjoyed and played through completely.

My Characters: Johasua - 73 Broa Chief Bandit

demon323k 09/11/10 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

[quote] Johasua : Fallout: New Vegas will win Game of the Year Fallout 3 was the only game ever that I really enjoyed and played through completely. [/quote] i really like fallout and halo but honestly i think starcraft 2 will win game of the year if not game of the decade.

My Characters: XjnarutojX - 97 Scania Chief Bandit

ThePepsi 09/11/10 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

[quote] PyreFang : This is a stupid question but... how does one go about deciding which is most enjoyed? By how many are sold within the first... oh wait I asked that. Seriously though: If each site has a different game of the year, does one just compile which game has the most sites calling it the game of the year? And that's the winner? [/quote] Whichever one is best overall. Each review website chooses their own Game of the Year, but most of them choose the same ones. Look for IGN and Gamespot's GOTY choices, those are the "big two"

My Characters: ExcelIerate - 41 Bera Brawler

TeefBlade 09/11/10 + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

halo sucks, period.

My Characters: SealedFates - 80 Scania Hermit

PyreFang + PM | QUOTE | PERMALINK | REPORT

[quote] ThePepsi : Whichever one is best overall. Each review website chooses their own Game of the Year, but most of them choose the same ones. Look for IGN and Gamespot's GOTY choices, those are the "big two" [/quote] Alright then. I usually pick my own personal "game of the year" (the one I've actually played that I enjoyed most) . I'm sure everyone does. Cause no one cares if a game is "game of the year" if they don't like it.

My Characters: iPyrefang - 15 Yellonde Magician